Pollinators, Neonicotinoids and Greenhouse Production
Populations of honey bees and native pollinators have declined worldwide in recent years. According to current research, a wide range of factors have contributed to their decline including parasites, disease, low genetic diversity, poor nutrition, loss of habitat, management stress and pesticides applied to crops.
The current state of honeybee health has been detailed in a joint comprehensive report released by the USDA and EPA: Report on the National Stakeholders Conference on Honey Bee Health
Concerning the role of pesticides, neonicotinoid insecticides have been implicated as a potential contributing factor. Neonicotinoid insecticides are insect neurotoxicants. They are primarily systemic, which means that the active ingredient may be absorbed by the roots and move through the entire plant including pollen and nectar. There is evidence that foraging bees may receive sublethal doses in pollen and nectar which may make bees more vulnerable to other stressors, or may combine with doses from contact with other treated plant material.
Neonicotinoids are also persistent in the environment and even as they degrade, they remain toxic to bees. Pollinators are particularly vulnerable to exposure to neonicotinoids that are sprayed on open flowers of insect pollinated plants or move systemically into pollen and nectar.
Neonicotinoids that are labeled for greenhouse ornamentals include Group 4 A insecticides:
- imidacloprid (AmTide Imidacloprid, Benefit, Bounty, Mantra, Mallet, Marathon, Quali-Pro Imidacloprid)
- thiamethoxam, (Flagship)
- acetamiprid (TriStar) and
- dinotefuran (Safari)
One other neonicotinoid, clothianidin, is not currently used in greenhouses, but is used in other green industries. Many neonicotinoid products are also currently available to home gardeners. See the link to the fact sheet “Protecting Honey Bees from Pesticides in Home Gardens and Landscapes” at the end of this article for trade names of products available to home gardeners.
Steps to reduce pesticide exposure to pesticides
Many non-neonicotinoid pesticides are also toxic to bees and native pollinators, including some pesticides used for organic production. Pesticides applied to protect crops can affect pollinators through multiple routes of exposure: direct contact with sprays, contact with treated surfaces, pesticide-contaminated dust or pollen particles that are collected or adhere to the body of the insect (and may be taken back to hive), and ingestion of pesticide-contaminated pollen and nectar.
Growers’ decisions make a difference in the level of exposure of bees and other beneficial insects to pesticides. Taking precautions to minimize pesticide poisoning of pollinators in all crops is an important responsibility of all pesticide applicators.
Reduce or eliminate the use of neonicotinoid insecticides
The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) or state governments may ban or restrict the use of neonicotinoid insecticides in the future. It has been reported that some mass markets will require neonicotinoid treated plants to be labeled.
Therefore, growers should consider reducing the use of and reliance on neonicotinoid insecticides. Only use neonicotinoid insecticides when other effective products do not exist and use neonicotinoids in ways that are protective of pollinators. Monitor crops for pests and spot-treat pests when they are first observed. Use environmentally sound alternatives whenever possible.
Avoid treating “Bee Friendly” plants
Avoid treating plants that are attractive to bees with neonicotinoid insecticides. These include many perennial and native plants and also annual bedding plants. Many retailers now market plants as “Bee Friendly”. These plants should never be treated with neonicotinoids, even during production.
When greenhouses are “opened up” for ventilation, for example side-walls rolled up, be aware of bee activity on plants, especially if pesticide applications are made during the day. Avoid applications when bees are actively foraging in a greenhouse. Make applications in the early morning, late in the day or at night when pollinators are not foraging. Control weeds under benches where bees may forage.
Research in European farmland found evidence that honeybees on average forage 1 mile from their hives, but may travel up to 6 miles. Effects would likely be greatest on hives within 1 mile of treated areas and decline for hives further away, as fewer and fewer bees will reach treated areas from distant locations.
Wettable powders, dusts and microencapsulated products have a greater toxic hazard than emulsifiable concentrates (or other liquid formulation with active ingredient in solution). Products that do not have acute toxicity but could cause injury to immature bees if carried back to the hive should not be applied in particulate form; this may include insect growth regulators.
Drying time before exposure
Some products are highly toxic when wet, but much less so after the pesticide is dried. Apply when there will be adequate drying time before pollinator activity.
If applying a pesticide in an outdoor production yard, avoid drift on non-target areas particularly onto clover and other flowering plants including weeds near the yard. Prior to treatment, mow weedy areas to reduce flowers that may be attractive to pollinators. Temperature inversion conditions, wind speed, application equipment characteristics and operator skill may influence drift.
Do not apply insecticides rated as ‘High’ or ‘Moderate’ directly to bees that are actively foraging on blooming crop or weeds. EPA registration includes an acute, single-dose laboratory study designed to determine the quantity of pesticide that causes 50% mortality (LD50) in a test population of bees.
Read the label for bee hazard rating
The EPA recently introduced a label change for insecticides used outdoors that contain one or more of the neonicotinoids in order to protect bees. Some of these pesticides are also be labeled for greenhouse use. Specifically, all insecticides which can be applied as outdoor foliar sprays (not granular) and contain the active ingredients chlothianidin, dinotefuran, imidacloprid or thiamethoxam will contain warning icons and directions for use to minimize impact on pollinators.
The Bee Hazard warning (see below) will be placed in the Environmental Hazards section of the pesticide label.
The EPA bee toxicity groupings and label statements are as follows:
High (H) Bee acute toxicity rating: LD50 = 2 micrograms/bee or less. The label has the following statement: "This product is highly toxic to bees and other pollinating insects exposed to direct treatment or residues on blooming crops or weeds. Do not apply this product or allow it to drift to blooming crops or weeds if bees or other pollinating insects are visiting the treatment area." If the residues phrase is not present, this indicates that the pesticide does not show extended residual toxicity.
Moderate (M) Product contains any active ingredient(s) with acute LD50 of greater than 2 micrograms/bee, but less than 11 micrograms/bee. Statement: "This product is moderately toxic to bees and other pollinating insects exposed to direct treatment or residues on blooming crops or weeds. Do not apply this product if bees or other pollinating insects are visiting the treatment area."
Low (L) All others. No bee or pollinating insect caution required.
In addition, specific use restrictions are placed in the “Directions for Use section.” See the full EPA text: https://www.epa.gov/pollinator-protection/new-labeling-neonicotinoid-pesticides.
Pest Management in Greenhouses
Many growers of greenhouse crops are minimizing their use of pesticides by using biological control to manage pests in their greenhouses. For information on pest management in greenhouses, see these fact sheets.
References and Resources
Note: The New England Greenhouse Floriculture Guide contains an expanded version of this article. Contributors to the new section of the guide “Protecting Bees and Pollinators from Pesticides” are Dr. Richard Cowles, The Connecticut Agricultural Experiment Station, Dr. Raymond Cloyd, Kansas State University, Dr. Kimberly Stoner, The Connecticut Agricultural Experiment Station and Dr. Lois Berg Stack, University of Maine.
Information on ordering the New England Greenhouse Floriculture Guide
- Clemson University. 2012. How to Protect Honeybee from Pesticides A Guide for Beekeepers Department of Pesticide Regulation Publication, Bulletin 5.
- Honeybee foraging in in differentially structured landscapes. http://rspb.royalsocietypublishing.org/content/270/1515/569.abstract
- How to Reduce Bee Poisoning From Pesticides. 2006. Oregon State University. https://www.cdfa.ca.gov/files/pdf/ReduceBeePesticideEffects.pdf
- Lanier, J. Neonicotinoids and Bees. UMass Turf Program. http://ag.umass.edu/fact-sheets/grub-control-in-lawns-neonicotinoids-bees
- New England Vegetable Guide: Protecting Honeybees and Native Pollinators. https://nevegetable.org/protecting-honeybees-and-native-pollinators
- Pesticide Task Force of the North American Pollinator Protection Campaign (NAPPC). http://pollinator.org/nappc/index.html
- Pollinator Protection - EPA Actions to Protect Pollinators. www.epa.gov/opp00001/ecosystem/pollinator/risk-mgmt.html
- Smitley D. Growing Flowering Plants That are Safe for Pollinators in the Yard and Garden. 2014. (powerpoint presentation with history and research). http://agbioresearch.msu.edu/uploads/396/52694/NeonicsandBees11-21-14.pdf
- Stoner K. Planting Flowers for Bees in Connecticut. http://www.ct.gov/caes/lib/caes/documents/publications/fact_sheets/entomology/planting_flowers_for_bees_in_connecticut.pdf
- Stoner K. Protecting Bees from Pesticides. http://www.ct.gov/caes/lib/caes/documents/publications/fact_sheets/entomology/protecting_pollinators_from_pesticides_-_fact_sheet_final.pdf
- The Xerces Society for Invertebrate Conservation. http://www.xerces.org/pollinator-conservation/
- USDA Report on the National Stakeholder Conference on Honey Bee Health, National Honey Bee Health Stakeholder Conference Steering Committee. 2012. https://www.usda.gov/sites/default/files/documents/ReportHoneyBeeHealth.pdf
- Wollaeger H.M., Getter K.L and B.K. Behe. 2015. Consumer Preferences for Traditional, Neonicotinoid-free, Bee-friendly, or Biological Control Pest Management Practices on Floriculture Crops. Department of Horticulture, Michigan State University. HortScience vol.50 (5 )pp 721-732. http://hortsci.ashspublications.org/content/50/5/721.abstract?etoc#fn-2
- White A. https://pollinatorgardens.org/
Fact Sheet available to be printed and distributed to home gardeners.
“Protecting Honey Bees from Pesticides in Home Gardens and Landscapes”
Extension Greenhouse Crops and Floriculture Program
University of Massachusetts, Amherst