Some New England winters are characterized by relatively mild temperatures, or at least by a lack of extreme cold. It is also not uncommon, however, for temperatures to dip to near record-breaking levels.
Following periods of extreme cold, many in the Green Industry ask about the impact such temperatures may have had on plant materials in the landscape. That kind of question is always difficult to answer with any certainty. There are just too many variables to be definitive. Cold injury varies with plant species, age, general vigor of the plant, and site and soil characteristics. Still, a review of potential damage to trees and shrubs may be beneficial to those in the field. Keep in mind that much of the damage that may have occurred will not become apparent until spring when new growth begins. By then, many people will have forgotten about a cold snap, especially during a mild spring, and may not relate the visible damage in spring to the extreme events of winter.
Before proceeding with a discussion of potential cold injury, there are some factors that may be eliminated. First, if the weather conditions of the previous fall favored proper hardening of plants, it is much less likely that cold injury could have occurred in mid-winter because plants were not properly hardened. When a warm period occurs prior to the onset of frigid weather, however, there is increased potential that physiological changes in plants could result in a reduction of hardiness.
It is also unlikely that the cold could have much if any impact on native plant materials in their natural habitats. The geographic range of native plants is determined by extreme temperatures and not by average temperatures. Having said that, it is entirely possible that native species which have been planted in urban or suburban landscapes where soils and environmental factors are vastly different from their normal habitat could experience cold injury due to stresses on the plants imposed by these exotic habitats.
Most woody ornamental species used in Massachusetts landscapes are non-native species. Nursery operators and landscape contractors rely on hardiness ratings to determine the potential survivability of each species in particular regions of the state. The ratings are usually based on field trials of the species in USDA-defined hardiness zones. Hardiness zones are determined by average low temperatures for a given region of the country, and not by extreme low temperatures. As such, planting a species rated hardy to Zone 6 in a Zone 6 area does not guarantee survival when the plant is exposed to extreme temperatures. Those species that are marginally hardy to a particular zone are especially vulnerable to cold injury. Keep that in mind when assessing plant problems in the spring.
Snow cover is also an important factor, as it provides natural insulation that can help to protect root systems. Significant root kill will certainly affect the survivability of landscape plants. It is known with certainty that roots of plants are much less hardy than are the shoots. However, soil by itself is a pretty good insulator and in most winters soil provides enough protection for roots to ensure plant survival. Once frozen, soil temperature remains fairly constant, at least at depths greater than 6 inches. If low temperatures affect roots, it is the roots nearest the surface that will be killed. The roots killed are feeder roots, since these are typically closest to the surface. The amount of damage will depend upon many factors: root hardiness, general depth of rooting for the species, soil texture (most root kill in response to cold seems to occur in sandy soils rather than clay soils), and the presence or absence of mulch. It should be noted that death of feeder roots during winter is not unusual. Kozlowski and Pallardy (Physiology of Woody Plants.1997. Academic Press) state that "the greatest mortality of small roots occurs during the cold months." Therefore, the question is not whether roots have been killed but to what extent they have been killed. The answer is normally apparent in spring.
While roots of plants in the landscape are afforded some protection against low temperatures by the surrounding soil, the roots of plants in above-ground planters or containers are much less protected. All of the roots within the container are subject to direct injury or death from the cold.
It may be that the greatest damage to roots will happen as a result of frost heaves. The lifting of soil that occurs when it freezes can break apart roots. Un-mulched fall planted trees and shrubs are most susceptible to injury from frost heaves because of the absence of extensive anchoring roots.
The amount of injury to above ground parts of plants in direct response to low temperatures is as uncertain as is the amount of damage to roots. As with roots, shoot injury will not usually become apparent until spring.
One type of cold injury that is most certain is the killing of flower buds on those trees and shrubs that are marginally hardy. Flower buds are typically less hardy than leaf buds. It has often been stated that the flower buds of Forsythia and peaches are prone to winter kill when temperatures drop to minus 15º F. The precision of that temperature threshold can be argued, especially when one considers cultivars and site factors.
Buds are not the only structures where differences in hardiness exist. In mid-winter, living xylem tissue tends to be less hardy than cambium and phloem tissue. It is xylem in smaller branches that is most prone to damage from low temperatures. If such damage has occurred, affected branches will be slow to leaf and/or flower in spring, or they may die. The xylem of cold damaged branches will appear to be black or darkened.
Cold injuries such as sun scald and frost cracks often occur in response to sudden and wide fluctuations in temperature of wood. This typically takes place on cold days when the sun warms the sunny side of the trunk to a temperature above freezing, causing some expansion of the wood. According to Harris (Arboriculture. 1992. Regents/Prentice Hall Publishing), the temperature of wood may differ by as much as 18º F from the air temperature on sunny days. For expansion of wood to take place due to warming, the temperature of the wood would have to rise to above freezing. If the temperatures during a cold spell remain far below freezing throughout the period, then warming and expansion of wood on sunny days may not be widespread. Nevertheless, such injury could occur and practitioners should examine the trunks and branches of woody plants for sun scald and frost cracks each spring.
Assessing winter injury: Because of limited root growth, it is not unusual to see newly planted specimens die after a brutal winter. In the worst years long established plants can die, including some native species. In most cases it is species which are marginally hardy that experience the most losses.
Usually winter damage does not become apparent until spring when growth normally resumes. Typically, winter damaged plants are slow to initiate growth, may show distorted growth, death of leaf and flower buds, or dieback of shoots and branches. In more challenging years, the plant species which have been damaged are often remarkably consistent across Massachusetts and the region.
Below is a list of plants widely observed to have died as a consequence of winter damage or have had significant winter injury (brown foliage, branch dieback, etc.) in the last several years. This list is compiled from observations by the Landscape, Nursery, and Urban Forestry team of UMass Extension:
- Burning bush
- Butterfly bush
- Ilex (crenata, opaca, glabra, meserve)
- Leyland cypress
- Oakleaf hydrangea
- Perennials - many species, especially silver and gray leaf species such as Artemisia and Achillea
- Roses - Note that new shoots can appearing at the base of some heavily damaged roses. On grafted roses, these shoots can often be seen to originate from the rootstock. Therefore, the resulting roses will not be true to variety.
What to do for those plants still alive but injured: The options for dealing with severely inured plants are limited. Basically, care at this point involves pruning out dead portions of affected plants. In addition, it is necessary to provide a good growing environment to eliminate sources of further stress. That means watering and mulching. Fertilizer is not needed. With pruning, the shoot to root balance shifts to the roots. Food reserves in roots - assuming there are ample roots that have not been winter killed - should support new growth in the remaining living parts of the shoot system. Addition of fertilizer will not influence the transport of food reserves to growing points on the shoot system.
In conclusion, the impact of winter events on the subsequent health and survival of woody plants is difficult to predict prior to spring growth. However, those events and the possible kinds of damage that they could cause to plants should be kept in mind when evaluating plant growth or death in spring.
Written by: Ron Kujawski