Managing Striped Cucumber Beetle in Vine Crops
Striped cucumber beetle is our most serious early-season pest in vine crops. These beetles spend the winter in plant debris in field edges, and with the onset of warm days and emergence of cucurbit crops, move rapidly into the field. Densities can be very high, especially in non-rotated fields or close to last year’s cucurbit crops. Adult feeding on cotyledons and young leaves can cause stand reduction and delayed plant growth. The striped cucumber beetle vectors (Erwinia tracheiphila), the causal agent of bacterial wilt, and this can be more damaging than direct feeding injury. Crop rotation, transplants, and floating row cover are cultural controls that help reduce the impact of cucumber beetles. Perimeter trap cropping gives excellent control with dramatic reduction in pesticide use.
For more detailed information on the identification, life cycle, crop injury, and cultural controls of this pest, please see our main Cucumber Beetle, Striped article.
Avoid early season infection with wilt. Cucurbit plants at the cotyledon and first 1-4 leaf stage are more susceptible to infection with bacterial wilt than older plants.
Thresholds and foliar controls
Beetle numbers should be kept low, especially before the 5-leaf stage. Scout frequently (at least twice per week for two weeks after crop emergence) and treat after beetles colonize the field. Early spot treatments of field edges can be helpful. The threshold depends on the crop. To prevent bacterial wilt in highly susceptible crops, we recommend that beetles should not be allowed to exceed one beetle for every 2 plants. Less wilt-susceptible crops (butternut, most pumpkins) will tolerate 1 or two beetles per plant without yield losses. Spray within 24 hours after the threshold is reached. Proper timing is key. There are a number of broad spectrum insecticides which can be used for foliar control (including Capture 2EC, Decis 1.5EC, Thoinex 50W, Asana, and Sevin). See the New England Vegetable Management Guide for more details.
OMRI-list insecticides available for use in organic cucurbits include kaolin clay (Surround WP), pyrethrin (Pyganic Crop Spray 5.0 EC), and spinosad (Entrust). In 2009 spray trials comparing these three products at the UMass Research Farm, kaolin was the most effective in reducing beetle numbers and feeding damage. There was a trend toward Surround WP being more effective when Pyganic or Entrust was mixed with it, but never significantly better than surround alone. Other studies have shown more efficacy from pyrethrin and spinosad. Surround should be applied before beetles arrive because it acts as a repellent and protectant -- beetles do not “recognize” the plant and so do not feed -- not a contact poison. With direct-seeded crops, apply as soon as seedlings emerge if beetles are active. Transplants can be sprayed before setting out in the field.
Two systemic neo-nicotinoid products, imidacloprid (Admire Pro) and thiamethoxam (Platinum), are registered for use in cucurbits. In New England, Platinum is labeled for use specifically for striped cucumber beetle only in MA and CT. These are systemic insecticides that may be used as an in-furrow, banded, drench, or drip irrigation application to the seed/seedling root zone during or after planting/transplanting operations. DO NOT apply as a foliar spray.
Using systemics in direct seeded crops
It is important to get the insecticide into the soil to avoid photochemical breakdown; placing it in the furrow or irrigating it in can accomplish this. One of the most efficient systems for an in-furrow treatment is to attach an injector to the planter for placement at the seed level after the furrow is opened and before the seed drops. This has the advantage of one trip through the field and very precise targeting of material. Where it is applied to the soil surface, it should be watered in with irrigation (or rainfall) to move it to root depth for seedlings.
Using systemics on transplants
The best time to treat is about 1 day prior to planting in the field. We have observed effective results at rates of 0.01 ml Admire Pro per plant. See label for application rates. Caution should be used because phytoxicity can occur at high rates. Note: there are 29.6 milliliters (ml) in one fluid oz.
Another way to apply imidacloprid to transplants is through a water wheel planter. Use the same rate per plant as you would for a transplant drench and the rate of water per plant that fits your planter (e.g. 8 oz). Multiply by the number of plants and mix the total insecticide needed with the total water needed in the tank. Make sure your workers wear protective gear including chemical resistant gloves and allow time for uptake (1+ days) into leaves Note that the highest rate of uptake will be into new growth.
Systemic seed treatments
The Farmore DI-400 seed treatment from Syngenta combines a systemic insecticide with three different fungicides in a seed treatment. We haven’t tested it ourselves, but we’ve heard that results are good, with 20-25 days of SCB control and no reduction in germination or plant health. The price is relatively low, as the seed treatment adds about $2-$3 per 1,000 seeds. It's registered for use on a wide variety of cucurbits, including cucumber, muskmelon, pumpkin, summer squash, winter squash, and watermelon.
A drip system can be used for Admire or Platinum applications to either direct seeded or transplanted crops. Know your system well enough to know how long it will take to inject a given amount of concentrated solution (eg one bucketful) and to soak the area between emitters. Apply early enough to allow the plant roots and leaves to take up the material before beetles arrive. The system should be primed with water first, and the insecticide injected slowly for even distribution. Make sure to use enough water to soak the area between emitters. More emitters provide more even distribution of product.
Calculate the total needed based on the rate per 100 or 1000 ft of row and the number of row feet of line that will be treated. Place the total amount in the bucket with enough water for 20-30 minutes of injection. Charge the system with water first to get the soil wet. Turn on the Venturi or other injector, to inject slowly for even distribution (20 or 30 minutes). Then flush lines with clear water and to move product out and down.
Bees are very susceptible to imidacloprid and thiamethoxam and could be affected by its presence in pollen if it is still at high levels in the plants at the time of flowering. Bees intoxicated by Admire or Platinum, like beetles, show unusual behaviors such as tremors, staggering, and falling over before dying. This could happen with bees at excessively high rates of these insecticides. The foliar formulation of imidacloprid (Provado)is not labeled for cucurbits, and the foliar formulation of thiamethoxam (Actara) has a label for cucurbits but may not be sprayed during bloom. Carbamates such as Sevin and synthetic pyrethroids should not be used during bloom to avoid killing bees. Given the high losses of hives over the past several years – which seems to be from multiple causes, only one of which is the pesticides used on crops that bees visit – taking precautions to protect both native and domestic bees is an especially important concern. Note that the 2010 edition of the New England Vegetable Management Guide gives rating for bee toxicity of insecticides in Table 20 (pg 49).
Resistance from overuse
The down side of systemic products might be that they are ‘too easy’. That’s not necessarily a bad thing for growers who are always too busy! However if these are overused on a routine basis, these products may well be lost to resistance in a fairly short time. Furthermore, they are not cheap. For a truly IPM approach, combine or alternate these materials with crop rotation, perimeter trap cropping, and field scouting followed by foliar sprays with other classes of insecticides to reduce the likelihood of resistance and keep use rates low. Perimeter trap cropping provides a large, untreated refuge which may delay resistance.
-Ruth Hazzard & Andrew Cavanagh, University of Massachusetts, updated for 2010.