Lettuce, Downy Mildew
Downy mildew (Bremia lactucae) is a common disease of lettuce in cooler growing environments, where temperatures are low and there are long periods of leaf wetness caused by overnight dew. These conditions are common in late-fall and in cool season greenhouses, and this fall we have seen downy mildew in field lettuce and in a heated winter greenhouse. Symptoms can include white sporulation on leaf surfaces and growers may see the white growth on leaves and assume they have powdery mildew. Importantly, downy mildew requires cool weather and leaf wetness while powdery mildew occurs during warm weather and under dry conditions. Downy mildew is caused by an oomycete like late blight and powdery mildew is caused by a fungus, so fungicides used to control one may not control the other. Be sure to properly identify the pathogen or submit a sample to the diagnostic lab.
The disease causes leaf yellowing in angular patches, as the spots are vein-limited. On red varieties the initial spots may appear more grayish and water-soaked. Under humid conditions, white crusty sporulation forms when sporangiophores emerge from stomata and produce sporangia in distinct white projections, as with brassica downy mildew. Sporulation usually forms on the underside of the leaf but may also be seen on the upper leaf surface. Later, lesions turn tan or brown and papery as the tissue is killed. Older leaves close to the ground usually are the first to show symptoms.
Downy mildew can reduce yields and quality of the crop. Infected wrapper leaves must be removed at harvest. Infections on the cap leaves or of leaf lettuce may result in leaving heads or whole plantings behind in the field. Mild infections may go unnoticed, if sporulation only occurs on lower leaves, but infections on the cap leaves or of leaf lettuce may require abandoning heads or whole plantings in the field. Sporulation can develop after harvest, resulting in symptomatic lettuce on market shelves. Downy mildew damaged leaf tissue can be an entry site for secondary rot producing organisms. These rot organisms may compound crop losses in the field, and can also cause losses later when the lettuce is in transit.
Damp, cool conditions and moisture on leaves are required for the pathogen to infect lettuce and cause symptoms to develop. The short-lived sporangia are dispersed by winds. Cultivated lettuce is the main host but it has also been reported on other plants such as artichoke, cornflower (Centaurea cyanus), and strawflower (Helichrysum bracteatum). Bremia lactucae is a complex organism, consisting of multiple races (pathotypes). Major pathotypes are numbered in both Europe and the U.S., and the numbering is separate between the two continents. Currently, 9 races have been identified in the U.S. and 37 have been identified in Europe, however US races 1-4 and EU races 1-15 are no longer active or important in the field, so economically important pathotypes are limited to US 5-9 and EU 16-37. However, the pathogen is highly complex and new races continue to occur as the pathogen changes. Within each pathotype, some isolates have developed a lack of sensitivity to some fungicides. It is not entirely clear whether or not B. lactucae produces more persistent overwintering spores (oospores) in our area, if it is blown in from other growing regions, or is associated with seed.
Planting resistant varieties is the most effective and strategy for preventing lettuce downy mildew. However, choosing the right resistant variety necessitates that one knows which strain(s) of the pathogen is present. Planting resistant varieties is the most effective strategy for preventing lettuce downy mildew. However, choosing the right resistant variety necessitates that one knows which strain(s) of the pathogen is present. Resistance is reported for EU and US strains separately; for example, the head lettuce variety ‘Muir’ is reported as having resistance to EU 16–26, 28, 32 and US 5–9. Because the pathogen is constantly changing and because there are so many more identified EU pathotypes than US pathotypes, the strongest resistance can be achieved by growing lettuce varieties with resistance to as many EU pathotypes as possible (despite not all of the EU pathotypes being present in the US). Resistance to newer pathotypes (e.g. higher numbers) may also provide better, broader protection against the newest, unnumbered pathotypes.
We are currently conducting experiments to determine the strain(s) present here in MA but this process may take some time. In the meantime, we are interested in hearing from anyone who has or has had the disease on their farm in the last few seasons to learn more about this disease and to compile a list of varieties which do and do not seem to get disease that growers could use. Please email or call Sue at email@example.com or 413-577-3976 and let us know when you have seen the disease and which varieties were and were not affected.
Other cultural controls may include:
- Destroying crop residues promptly after harvest
- Crop rotation into unaffected fields
- Buying quality seed
- Reducing leaf wetness by using drip irrigation, increasing spacing, orienting rows parallel with wind, controlling weeds, and so on
- Heat and vent greenhouses to remove moist air
Many fungicides are labeled to control downy mildew and can be effective if a spray program is started early, before disease occurs when conditions are favorable. Oomycete-specific materials (e.g. Tanos, Ranman,Curzate) should be mixed with a broad spectrum fungicide (e.g. mancozeb or copper). For organic growers, contact fungicides e.g. Oxidate or Milstop on a tight spray schedule (no residual activity) have been found by growers to be most effective. See the New England Vegetable Management Guide for a complete list of registered fungicide. Check labels for pre-harvest intervals.
Crops that are affected by this disease:
The Center for Agriculture, Food and the Environment and UMass Extension are equal opportunity providers and employers, United States Department of Agriculture cooperating. Contact your local Extension office for information on disability accommodations. Contact the State Center Director’s Office if you have concerns related to discrimination, 413-545-4800 or see ag.umass.edu/civil-rights-information.